While we all emerge from our holiday slumber, the big story domestically remains that Saskatchewan is planning to move ahead with their plans to stop collecting the carbon levy on heat, and hoping that they won’t suffer any repercussions for it. This includes trying to put forward some legal fictions like trying to register the Government of Saskatchewan that’s the seller of natural gas and electricity rather than Crown corporations like SaskEnergy, which the federal government would be well within their rights to reject outright because it’s a fig leaf attempting to protect those Crown corps for breaking federal law. And to add to that, the provincial minister has been spinning the falsehood that the federal “pause” on heating oil won’t reduce the rebate, and that the rebates in his province should be secure if they stop collecting the levy, which is also false–the rebates will be reduced because that money comes from collecting the carbon price—it’s not a federal entitlement programme out of general revenue.
Here’s University of Alberta’s Andrew Leach with more:
The violation of federal law will not be by the Minister but by the Directors and Officers of @SaskEnergy. The federal act is clear: the entity that distributes the gas is responsible for remitting the carbon levy. Scott Moe can't insert his government in their place. https://t.co/St3thOWaUa
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) December 30, 2023
The Government of Saskatchewan is pretending that it can register as the distributor and supplant SaskEnergy's responsibility. It can't. There is no sense in which the office of the Minister "carries on the business of selling, delivering or distributing [natural gas]." pic.twitter.com/2MF1lW6Vcp
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) December 31, 2023
And, if SaskEnergy does not remit those charges *intentionally*, here's what happens (s 135) and the section that tells you it applies to Directors and Officers (s 138). This is all in addition to actually having to remit the unpaid carbon charges and penalties for non-payment. pic.twitter.com/dpVTYn66fW
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) December 31, 2023
Law(s I like) and order (when it suits me) conservatives are hilarious.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) December 31, 2023
Neither the SCC nor the Federal Court ruled that the Minister of the Environment violated any laws. They ruled that statutes and/or administrative regulation were unconstitutional. That's an important distinction. Premier Moe is directing entities to violate federal law.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) December 31, 2023
And, yes, the reduction in carbon tax charged on heating oil will, absolutely, lead both to lower average rebates and possibly a recovery of some paid earlier this year.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 3, 2024
Now, just so we're clear, I fully expect the carbon levy to be paid, in which case rebates would not be affected, but that presumes that Scott Moe is going to fold like a cheap suit and I don't want to be rude.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 3, 2024
In case you missed it:
- My Xtra story on the Ontario court decision that ruled that calling queer people and drag queens “groomers” is a slur and is not protected speech.
- My weekend column on an NDP private member’s bill initiative on a Middle East peace plan that looks like a Kickstarter, but is promising things it cannot deliver.
- My column on the complete lack of serious responses in any of the Conservatives’ year-ender interviews (and the ongoing attempts to justify their Ukraine votes).
- My year-ender column traces how the shift and fragmentation of social media turned the our politics into an even more toxic snake pit than ever.
- My latest column on Poilievre’s “debt bomb” disinformation documentary and why it’s just hysteria to rile up the Boomers and Gen-Xers.
- My Loonie Politics Quick Take on the way the housing issue is going to dominate the political scene for the foreseeable part of 2024.
Ukraine Dispatch:
Kyiv and Kharkiv have come under heavy bombardment in the past several days, in particular striking apartment buildings. There have been Ukrainian drone strikes in the Russian province of Belgorod.
A maternity ward, educational facilities, a shopping mall, multi-story residential buildings and private homes, a commercial storage, and a parking lot. Kyiv, Lviv, Odesa, Dnipro, Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia, and other cities.
Today, Russia used nearly every type of weapon in its… pic.twitter.com/q5q8Q98Njr
— Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) December 29, 2023
We’re starting the year with active work to further strengthen Ukraine, particularly our air defense, in the wake of brutal Russian air attacks.
I just had my first call this year with @JustinTrudeau. We focused primarily on security. I informed him about Russia’s most recent… pic.twitter.com/DpYx9wJaYe
— Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) January 1, 2024