Sometimes you see a terrible column, and sometimes there’s such a piece of hot garbage that you need to don a hazmat suit just to approach it and get hosed off afterward like you just came out of a leaking nuclear reactor. The Toronto Sun’s Christina Blizzard delivered one of those yesterday.
In which Christina Blizzard calls for an end to responsible government in Ontario. https://t.co/qgtszjQYHL
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
.@davidreevely pic.twitter.com/ntSE67hSdw
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) September 14, 2016
That’s right – this columnist thinks that the lieutenant governor should threaten Kathleen Wynne to shape up or she’ll dismiss her, because 167 years of Responsible Government was just a failed experiment. One lesbian first minister in this province and we’ve decided that it was too much – time to hand power back to the queen and be done with it.
The last LG to do it was then himself dismissed by the feds, according to Blizzard's authority.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
(She doesn't mention that part.)
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
Blizzard calls on Dowdeswell to do this explicitly because the voters are idiots and can't be trusted.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
You see! Voters can’t be trusted! Obviously we’d be better off under absolute monarchy again because they won’t let such terrible governments to let themselves get elected and then implement the agendas that they were elected on. It’s like the fanboys in the First Order who remember the good old days of the Galactic Empire and preferred it to the messy democracy of the New Republic.
Maybe you remember the last time a viceroy asserted himself. Lord Byng denied Mackenzie King a dissolution.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
When the following minority government collapsed instantly, Mackenzie King ran on the issue and was resoundingly re-elected.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
And that was pretty much the end of viceroys thinking they had power in situations like this. Viz Michaelle Jean and prorogation.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
The LG does what the premier tells her to because that's how our democracy works.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
It’s called confidence. Whichever leader in the legislature or Parliament that can command the confidence of the chamber gets to advise the LG/GG/queen on how to exercise the powers of state. Not a difficult concept.
The system has its problems. But one in which LGs dismiss premiers is so much worse.
— David Reevely (@davidreevely) September 14, 2016
It is utterly galling that a columnist can be so utterly ignorant of basic civics that this is the kind of utter bilge that they spew onto newsprint. We do have a problem with basic civic literacy in this country, and when you have columnists like this spreading complete nonsense out of some sense of partisanship, it gives a warped impression to people who read this and makes them believe that it’s actually normal and expected that the GG or the LG can boss around a government that you don’t like. No. Absolutely not.
https://twitter.com/pmlagasse/status/775866168863260672
https://twitter.com/pmlagasse/status/775866395414372352
https://twitter.com/pmlagasse/status/775866681998635008
That can't be right. I keep hearing that the Crown can and must dismiss the PM if I don't like him/her.
— Stephen Gordon (@stephenfgordon) September 14, 2016
https://twitter.com/pmlagasse/status/775868249749807108
So let me reiterate that Blizzard’s column is utter hot garbage. If the Sun had any shame, they’d pull it and apologise profusely for putting it out there, and Blizzard would be sent to a remedial civics course, but I doubt that’s going to happen because she’s just passionate about how bad Wynne is, or some bullshit excuse like that. So in the meantime, I’ll just leave this here:
As a reminder to two-bit columnists who spout nonsense like Blizzard, I have a book coming out about our system: https://t.co/RTe6yZPutn
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) September 14, 2016