Global News was at it again yesterday, and citing two anonymous sources, accused Liberal MP Han Dong of meeting with Chinese consular officials to counsel them against freeing the two Michaels, because doing so would somehow assist the Conservatives. Buried in the story is a throwaway line that CSIS has been tracking Dong’s calls with the consulate, which is a pretty big deal if true. But there’s a whole lot in this report that is troubling and suspect.
This is shocking information, but I don’t think it meets the threshold for foreign interference. Here’s why: elected officials in democracies can/should engage with diplomats. That’s how our system works. BUT: those infractions should not be clandestine/deceptive/threatening. 1/3 https://t.co/Qn0Ji1IsLS
— Akshay Singh (@Akshay_Thinks) March 22, 2023
Lastly, I’d like to put forward another reminder that intelligence is not evidence. We don’t know the source of many bits of info coming out now and/or what the motivations of these sources are. Even SIGINT can be problematic in certain instances. 3/3
— Akshay Singh (@Akshay_Thinks) March 22, 2023
First of all, that there are two anonymous sources doesn’t really mean much because they could be using the same intelligence report. Intelligence is not evidence, and we’ve been over this time and again. Also, if Dong is an agent of the Chinese government, why would he be giving them advice on the matter rather than relaying Beijing’s lines in Canada? And how exactly would Beijing freeing the two Michaels help the Conservatives? (One Conservative strategist tweeted that having the two Michaels detained gave the Liberals cover to avoid making any decisions on things like Huawei, which still doesn’t make sense because the signals to industry were crystal clear at this point). The fact that he called the consulate without informing PMO or the minister of foreign affairs is the potentially problematic thing here, but even then, it makes it hard to use this as some kind of proof that he is an agent of their interests. But there is a pattern in this reporting about making salacious claims that are very hard to square with how things operate, particularly in the political sphere.
Here’s the thing: these anonymous sources could be using the same information, so their independence isn’t assured, and neither is the veracity of the intelligence. We also don’t know the source of the info: wiretaps, human sources, other…. https://t.co/rIifOG1JFd
— JMDavis (@JessMarinDavis) March 23, 2023
Also: https://t.co/zO4nSXH81t
— JMDavis (@JessMarinDavis) March 23, 2023
https://twitter.com/StephanieCarvin/status/1638701542525087747
In the wake of these allegations, Dong has resigned from caucus and will sit as an independent (and the video of his speech is pretty devastating to watch), and it’s because he was not afforded due process, or any kind of fundamental justice or the ability to face his accusers. One would hope for a bit of reflection when it comes to the media ethics (or lack thereof) on display here, but sadly I doubt that’s going to happen.
Han Dong informs the House that he will now sit as an independent MP after Global News reported, citing unnamed sources, he secretly advised a Chinese diplomat in 2021 to delay freeing Michael Spavor and Michael Kovrig. "What has been reported is false and I will defend myself." pic.twitter.com/kSX8rAbWCJ
— Power & Politics (@PnPCBC) March 23, 2023
If this ever results in Criminal charges, am sure that these leaks will make securing a conviction before a court almost impossible. This violates so many principles of fundamental justice it makes me sick.
— Artur Wilczynski (@Arturmaks) March 23, 2023
Ukraine Dispatch:
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy visited troops near the front lines at Bakhmut yesterday, while Russians rained more missiles down on the country, hitting an apartment building in Zaporizhzhia and a university dorm near Kyiv.
President @ZelenskyyUA visited frontline positions in the Donetsk region and awarded the defenders of Bakhmut. pic.twitter.com/1uEAKtDg9n
— Defense of Ukraine (@DefenceU) March 22, 2023
https://twitter.com/defenceu/status/1638659920831606784
https://twitter.com/gerashchenko_en/status/1638495718640893953