Today is the day, where the prime minster is meeting with the provincial and territorial premiers to lay out the future of health transfers, and from the sounds if it, it’s not a negotiation. The Senior Liberal Sources™ are pointing to a ten-year deal with an expansion to the main Canada Health Transfer, as well as individual deals with provinces that focus on their priorities, and yes, there will be strings attached to that money. Trudeau is framing this conversation in a way that talks a lot about data, but the more unspoken part of that is the fact that the point of that data is so that there can be outcomes that can be compared across jurisdictions, and not have it in a format where it takes six months or a year for researchers to compile the data in a way that’s usable, because each province reports their data differently. People often don’t realise that it’s one of the reasons why we have such poor statistical data in this country, which is because provinces (who are responsible for vital statistics) don’t report in a way that is consistent, and it takes StatsCan or other agencies like CIHI time to make the data work.
Framing the conversation. https://t.co/XtAmpkCSlt
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) February 7, 2023
The other reason for strings, of course, is that provinces have a demonstrated history of not using health transfers on their healthcare systems. For the decade that health transfers rose at six percent annually, health spending in most provinces rose by somewhere around 2.2 percent annually, meaning a lot of that money got spent elsewhere. Andrew Coyne tweeted data going back 20 years, and it’s very noticeable the gap between what the federal government sent to provinces for healthcare, and what actually got spent on it. Given how much additional pandemic spending went directly to provinces’ bottom lines during the pandemic, there is no longer an appetite for this to continue, which is why strings are not only important, but need to be in place, and it looks like the premiers have finally run out of room in the court of public opinion to operate otherwise.
This is exactly it. And before anyone says it, this happened under all premiers of all political stripes over those two decades, who have all consistently cried poor when it was their spending choices that led here. https://t.co/lYyVqSGzMS
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) February 7, 2023
https://twitter.com/acoyne/status/1622760959977656321
Ukraine Dispatch, Day 349:
Russian forces have been keeping up the pressure in the eastern part of Ukraine while they prepare for a new offensive, likely around the anniversary of the start of the invasion, and there are worries they could be putting that pressure in Donetsk so that they can launch a surprise attack in the south. As well, there has been shelling around Zaporizhzhia.
President Zelensky sent President Erdogan and the Turkish nation his condolesnces, as well as pledged readiness to provide necessary support to tackle the outcomes of the tragedy.
An important message keeping in mind Turkey's previous support of Ukraine.#TurkeyQuake https://t.co/nTVk6Z18vO
— UkraineWorld (@ukraine_world) February 6, 2023
Firing from tanks, mortars and artillery, the rashists shelled Dvorichna, Kucherivka, Ivanivka, Kyslivka and Kotlyarivka in Kharkiv region; Novoselivs'ke, Stel'makhivka, Ploshchanka, Chervonopopivka, Kreminna and Dibrova in Luhansk region; and Terny in Donetsk region.
2/2 pic.twitter.com/ERcEKMluTE
— Michael MacKay (@mhmck) February 7, 2023
Good reads:
- Justin Trudeau says that Canada is ready to assist allies with aid they need around the earthquake in Türkiye and Syria.
- François-Philippe Champagne and Pablo Rodriguez gave the new chair of the CRTC her marching orders in a public letter.
- Marco Mendicino says that any foreign agent registry will need the buy-in from cultural communities in Canada lest it turn into a tool of stigmatisation.
- As part of the government’s Ocean Protection Plan, there is investment in deep sea research; coastal First Nations chiefs have endorsed the marine protected area plan.
- Canada is expanding its temporary work permit programme for Hong Kong residents.
- The deputy minister of Public Services and Procurement says that McKinsey’s global record isn’t enough to disqualify it from Canadian government contracts.
- The new Indigenous languages commissioner says he hopes to have his office fully operational by summer.
- A labour tribunal has found that Parliament hasn’t been protecting the health and safety of its translation staff. Gosh, you think?
- A man has been arrested for making death threats against the Liberal MP for Kichener—Conestoga, Tim Louis.
- Former Liberal MP Raj Grewal wants the breach of trust charges laid against him during his time in office dismissed for lack of evidence.
- The Conservatives are calling on the Auditor General to probe the McKinsey contracts, for no reason other than they’re building a conspiracy theory.
- All opposition parties are peformatively demanding answers from the government about the Chinese “spy balloon.”
- Quebec’s immigration minister is freaking out after reports that New York City is providing free bus tickets to asylum seekers trying to reach Roxham Road.
- Matt Gurney explains why the gun control changes were an impossibility and a trap of the Liberals’ own making, which is why they had to walk them back.
- Colin Horgan notes the Conservatives building conspiracy theories and trying to use the Unreal in order to tap into dark impulses in voters, as QAnon has done.
Odds and ends:
Absolutely everybody: Don’t focus on McKinsey, the problem is use of outside consultants. McKinsey is small potatoes.
Conservatives: Let’s bring in the Auditor General to probe those McKinsey contracts. McKinsey! McKinsey! McKinsey! pic.twitter.com/9hvgNbfRid— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) February 6, 2023
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.