Another day, and another warning from the Speaker that a private member’s bill is going to need a royal recommendation before the final vote, and it won’t get it, so be prepared to waste everyone’s time on a doomed bill that won’t go anywhere. This is becoming increasingly routine in this parliament, where MPs keep advancing these bills that have no hope of passage up for debate, apparently because they want to be seen talking about the issue, and maybe shaming the government for not supporting it, as with this particular bill on enhancing OAS and GIS benefits for seniors between 65 and 74 (ignoring that they are enriched for seniors over 75 because many of them have exhausted their savings by that point).
Once again, it’s another private members’ bill that needs a royal recommendation. This is happening more and more this Parliament. https://t.co/iJkC2D4Sgc
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) May 11, 2023
But seriously—a private member’s bill cannot spend money. Only a government bill can do so, because they’re the government, and they need that expenditure approved by Parliament. This is fundamental to how parliamentary democracy works. These clear delineations in roles exists for a reason, and the role of MPs who are not in Cabinet is to hold Cabinet to account, and the primary way to do that is through the power of the public purse. You cannot hold them to account if you too are spending public money with abandon because you have at that point blurred the responsibilities and the lines of accountability. This shouldn’t be difficult for MPs to learn and grasp, but unfortunately, they have picked up a lot of bad habits and wrong-headed beliefs over the past number of years, and it’s becoming quite obvious that they either refuse to learn how the Chamber and the institution work, or they simply don’t care and would rather waste everyone’s time.
Ukraine Dispatch:
The Ukrainian commander in the ruins of Bakhmut says that Russian Wagner Group mercenaries have stepped up their attacks in recent days, while Russia is denying claims that Ukrainian forces have made advancements in Bakhmut over the past couple of days. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy says that the spring counter-offensive is being delayed because they need more western weapons. This while the UK has opted to send newer cruise missiles to Ukraine, who have the longest range of any of their arsenal to date. Zelenskyy also says he has approved a plan to reform criminal and law enforcement systems, which is a requirement for future EU membership.
❗ On 11 May, Russian occupiers launched a missile attack on the city of Toretsk in Donetsk Oblast, injuring at least six people. #StopRussia
Source: Head of the Presidential Office Andriy Yermak pic.twitter.com/O9RIuZxga4
— UkraineWorld (@ukraine_world) May 11, 2023
On Thursday afternoon, Russian troops shelled the town of Vovchansk in Kharkiv Oblast with artillery. Rescuers pulled a wounded woman from the rubble. #RussiaIsATerroristState
Source: Main Directorate of the State Emergency Service in Kharkiv Oblast pic.twitter.com/Xv2AyESPWC
— UkraineWorld (@ukraine_world) May 11, 2023
https://twitter.com/defencehq/status/1656535955338063873