While Ontario Premier Doug Ford doubles down on his assertion that a carbon tax will drive the economy into recession, in the face of all evidence to the contrary. And it’s not just Ford’s doubling down on this assertion – the Saskatchewan government is also insisting that the report it commissioned on the effect of carbon taxes is correct, despite the fact that the other experts who’ve looked it over say that the report vastly overestimates the effect by orders of magnitude. But as with Ford (and Andrew Scheer), it’s not about truth – it’s about taking any crumb of data that they think will fit with their narrative and blowing it so far out of proportion that it becomes an outright lie.
Saskatchewan's government also claimed carbon tax would bring a recession. Researchers found they badly misread the numbers. https://t.co/TZEZIF1pFX
— Jason Markusoff (@markusoff) January 22, 2019
https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt/status/1087768772436463617
Luckily, there is lots of thinking on this. For example, here are estimates from about a dozen different models in the US. Impacts of a carbon price range from slightly negative to slightly positive, depending on the model and scenario. None show substantial impacts. pic.twitter.com/RKMxYWgBdB
— Nic Rivers (@riversNic) January 21, 2019
Our analysis shows the overall economic impacts of a carbon price rising to $100/tonne + revenue recycling are very modest https://t.co/AIaiYW0Nss pic.twitter.com/DHxqaH5JSc
— Ecofiscal Commission (@EcofiscalCanada) January 21, 2019
But beyond that, the way in which this issue is being framed in the media should be questioned – something economist Mike Moffatt did over the Twitter Machine yesterday.
https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt/status/1087670357757227009
https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt/status/1087673953819287552
And he’s got a point – the CBC’s own story to debunk Ford’s claims is headlined “Economists cool to Doug Ford’s warning of ‘carbon tax recession’,” which again frames this as Ford versus economists – something that plays directly into Ford’s hands because he can turn around and claim that this is just the out-of-touch elites in their ivory towers and not “real folks,” a populist construction that is again built on a foundation of lies. And yet we in the media can’t seem to help ourselves because we don’t want to be seen as being biased, even when we are subjected to bald-faced lies, and again, we need to look like we’re being fair to the liars who are lying to our faces, which they take full advantage of. We’re hurting ourselves, but we can’t seem to help ourselves.
Those with a vested interest in misinformation have figured out that both-sidesism is the Achilles heel of the media, and they have exploited it to its fullest extent, knowing that they can lie with impunity and it will be framed as being a side in an argument. https://t.co/jWcTfAYNTZ
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) January 22, 2019