Pierre Poilievre held a media availability in Vancouver yesterday to promise that he would undo the changes to the capital gains taxes, spinning some bullshit provided to him by Jack Mintz about how this kills tens of thousands of jobs, when in reality it only provides a loophole for self-incorporated wealthy individuals to pay less tax—a fact that the Liberals were too incompetent to properly communicate. But this wasn’t the biggest whopper of the event. When asked by the media about where he stands on potential export taxes on oil exports as retaliation from Trump, Poilievre claimed that the Liberals blocked pipelines and LNG terminals, forcing Canadians to export more to the US, which gives Trump more leverage. Absolutely nothing about his is true. None of it. And with receipts, here’s Andrew Leach.
Under the administration of PMSH, two major export pipelines were built, and one was reversed and expanded. Enbridge Alberta Clipper (line 67) from Hardisty to Superior, Wisc., Keystone from Hardisty to Steele City, Indiana, and Line 9 from Sarnia to Montreal. https://t.co/9SFUGzthzo
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 16, 2025
Building pipelines to tidewater would have meant losing money on every barrel (under status quo and prevailing forecasts) which didn't foresee the US fracking boom. That's why we pushed more capacity into the US market.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 16, 2025
Sorry, Steele City Nebraska with a spur to Patoka, Illinois. Not sure how I got Indiana in there.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 16, 2025
There’s more. In fact, another whole thread here about the history of Northern Gateway that Poilievre has memory-holed in order to create a false version of history to blame Trudeau rather than note the lack of action under the Harper government. (First tweet below)
I would love to hear @PierrePoilievre sketch out the sequence of events a government could have followed to get a pipeline built to the west coast. The application for Gateway was filed in May, 2010. The Harper government was in office for five and a half more years after that. pic.twitter.com/ZR2bgzpRus
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 16, 2025
A reminder, for those engaged in revisionist history this week: pic.twitter.com/m0V0ROlrYN
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 17, 2025
And then Danielle Smith tried to start chiming in about an Alberta-first “Team Canada” approach grounded entirely in fantasy.
This is like a little city kid asking for a pony. Let's play it out: how can construction begin immediately on NGP or Energy East? In the case of EE, there has been no regulatory approval, no detailed route, limited consultation with indigenous peoples and there is no proponent. https://t.co/26lXFiVHLW
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 17, 2025
If you repeal 'c-69', we have no federal pipe permitting or op rules. We have no Canadian Energy Regulator. That might be a problem when you think about beginning construction on a new pipeline that has no shipper support and no detailed route. But who needs a yard for a pony?
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 17, 2025
Selling our gas to Europe? We literally had a proposal on the east coast. Why do you think it could not secure commercial (ie business) commitments for shipping LNG out of Nova Scotia? Our oil? They've been trying to exclude it from their market for decades.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 17, 2025
And just because…
Another one for @PierrePoilievre: Kitimat LNG had received fed and prov permits as an import facility by Aug 2006. Approval was shifted in 2008 for an export facility, w 20-yr export license granted
November 14, 2011. What should have been done differently in the next 4 years?— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 16, 2025
Let's run a test to see if Danielle Smith is serious. Northern Gateway was announced in 2004 and by 2006 had commercial commitments secured. From there, PMSH was in office for 9 years and the pipeline didn't get started. What should have been done differently? https://t.co/5V3isRyDbr
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) January 17, 2025
But unfortunately, today is not that day. https://t.co/mS0dKlP7C5
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) January 16, 2025
Ukraine Dispatch
Ukraine downed 34 out of 55 Russian drones overnight Thursday, but debris damaged energy infrastructure in Poltava region. There was a further drone attack on Kyiv as UK prime minister Keir Starmer was visiting. Ukrainian forces have begun using remote-controlled ground assault vehicles. Ukraine attacked a major Russian gunpowder factory in the Tambov region.
Critically lacking manpower on the front lines where Russia continues to use its vast manpower advantage to make grinding advances, Ukraine has been scrambling specialists into the infantry in an effort to replenish losses.https://t.co/nXSg4cAag4
— The Kyiv Independent (@KyivIndependent) January 16, 2025
A Russian drone flew over the Mariinsky Palace in Kyiv as President Volodymyr Zelensky was meeting U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Jan. 16, The Guardian reported.
The drone was spotted and heard buzzing above the Mariinsky Palace, a presidential residence, located not far…
— The Kyiv Independent (@KyivIndependent) January 16, 2025
Good reads:
- Justin Trudeau named a Canada-US relations council which has some national labour and business leaders, as well as premiers who dealt with Trump before.
- In a brief media availability, Trudeau called on Pierre Poilievre to spell out if he stands with Canada or Danielle Smith against Trump’s predations.
- Jonathan Wilkinson has spent days meeting with Republicans, and no one can give a straight answer on what Trump’s tariff plans actually are.
- Health Canada has no plans to ban certain synthetic red food dyes like the US has, because it hasn’t met the criteria for human harm.
- After meeting with Trudeau ahead of his meeting with the premiers, national Indigenous leaders want more involvement in the Trump tariff talks.
- Here is a look at the strategic considerations in Greenland which Trump would be coveting (aside from expansion for the sake of expansion).
- Disinformation was circulating online about the PM’s ski vacation, which not only didn’t happen, but was circulating before he was even at the ski hill in question.
- Mark Carney officially launched his campaign, talking a lot about playing hockey and getting the economy back on track (as though there are never any other issues).
- Althia Raj hears from sources™ that both Carney and Freeland are ready to scrap the consumer carbon levy (which is absolutely infuriating).
- My Xtra column highlights how the Liberal leadership is an opportunity for LGBTQ+ communities to remind candidates their issues still exist amidst “woke” accusations.
Odds and ends:
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.
Why can’t I read rebuttals like Andrew Leach’s to Polievre and Danielle Smith in mainstream outlets? I feel like I read a lot. I spend a few hundred a year on subscriptions but I can’t buy them all. I don’t tend to click on the x links because I don’t want anything to do with Elon musk and you can’t see the whole thread without signing up.
I’d love to find what Stephen Harper and Polievre said about that pipeline but where?
I don’t know, you’re all kind of writing for each other. This column is a gem, and I’m much better informed, especially because of the reading recommendations. But it makes me sick, thinking of the next election with Polievre lying his face off and the other candidates constantly off balance. His little speech will be run again and and again and I’ll only see the rebuttal here.
> I don’t tend to click on the x links because I don’t want anything to do with Elon musk and you can’t see the whole thread without signing up.
I’m reminded of the saying, “Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer”.