Roundup: Just which system is privileging the party?

Posted on by

Yesterday morning, the charlatans at Fair Vote Canada put out a press release that, straight-faced, said that Pierre Poilievre’s refusal to let his MPs advocate for Housing Accelerator funding is because the current single-member plurality voting system means that it’s always “party first,” which is hilarious because one of the defining features of proportional representation, which they advocate for, is that it privileges the parties over the MPs—so much so that certain PR systems don’t even allow for independents because of how the voting is structured.

Hilarious nonsense from the charlatans at Fair Vote Canada.PR privileges parties over MPs. This kind of behaviour would be worse under PR, not better, because the party has more control over individual MPs, not less.

— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2024-11-18T14:30:33.890Z

Their argument was more along the lines of “If you have more than one member in a riding, they don’t have to fight to be the sole voice” or something like that, which is only a feature in certain forms of PR (because there are many), but one that is wholly unworkable in Canada. Why? Because of our vast geographic distances. Some ridings are already the size of France, and allowances need to be made for some of these rural and remote ridings to have a smaller population than the median riding size because the distance is just too great otherwise. Each of the Territories is a good example of that. Expanding those ridings to be multi-member is a non-starter, and if you think that means that we can have two different systems—multi-member ridings in cities, single-member ridings in rural and remote areas—well, good luck convincing the Supreme Court of Canada that the inequities are constitutional.

Nevertheless, it will never not be hilarious for Fair Vote Canada to try and claim that the current system puts the party first when in actual fact, it privileges the rights of individual MPs to make their own choices, and allows them the freedom to buck their party lines if they have the spine to do so, because they are elected as an individual, not as a name on a party list. That matters a lot in terms of the rights of an MP, and for them to dismiss it is yet another sign that they’re a bunch of pretenders who don’t actually understand the system, or let alone enough to want to change it for some hand-waving that pretends it will be a panacea to problems when in fact it will just trade one set of problems for a new set that could very well be worse.

Especially when it consists of three-word slogans, or feel-good pabulum.

— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2024-11-18T14:18:06.943Z

Ukraine Dispatch

A Russian missile hit a residential building in Sumy late Sunday, killing 11l and wounding over 89. On Monday, a missile hit a residential neighbourhood in Odesa, killing ten and wounding over forty-four. President Zelenskyy visited the frontline towns of Pokrovsk and Kupiansk. The Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons has found evidence of Russia using tear gas last month in battles in the Dnipropetrovsk region. Here is a look at how the 1000 days of Russia’s invasion have changed the landscape of drone warfare, and what the invasion has cost Ukraine. Here is a look at what the US’ decision to allow Ukraine to use its weapons for strikes in Russian territory could mean.

https://twitter.com/ukraine_world/status/1858432305305424302

Good reads:

  • At the G20 in Brazil, Justin Trudeau had his first meeting with Mexico’s new president, as well as a thirty-minute bilateralwith Joe Biden.
  • Anita Anand says that out an “abundance of caution,” they are temporarily increasing screening of travellers to India.
  • Mental health and addictions minister Ya’ara Saks is looking for pitches for the $500 million fund to help youth afford mental health services.
  • MPs passed a unanimous motion to condemn the alleged Iranian plot to kill former justice minister Irwin Cotler.
  • Speaker Fergus warned MP Heather McPherson that her watermelon pin (a symbol of Palestinian support) may cross the line into being a prop, but will say more later.
  • Conservatives spent the day calling on Randy Boissonnault to resign.
  • The Alberta health minister is planning to revamp Alberta Health Services as “Acute Care Alberta,” which aims to solely be an oversight body.
  • Alberta’s Auditor General says the province isn’t providing any data on whether its affordable housing units are safe. (There’s a shocker).
  • Alberta is also letting insurance companies raise premiums with the promise that they’ll move to a no-fault system that might lower them (temporarily).

Odds and ends:

My Loonie Politics Quick Take looks at the defeatist reaction to the Environment Commissioner’s report by the Conservatives, which is not what he advocated.

Need a copy of my book “The Unbroken Machine,” or “Royal Progress,” which I contributed to? Want to give a copy as a gift? Dundurn Press is having a 25% off site wide sale!

— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2024-11-18T23:53:05.945Z

Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.