The stupid season is about to begin as MPs return to Parliament today, and lo, Pierre Poilievre primed his caucus in a meeting yesterday with a speech that decried the carbon levy as creating a “nuclear winter” for the economy. It’s absolute horseshit, because the carbon levy is not the cause of inflation or the cost-of-living challenges we’ve faced (and in fact, climate change is a major contributor to it), but this is Poilievre, and truth doesn’t matter.
They'll be eating the cats… pic.twitter.com/g7eXCtAfXL
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) September 16, 2024
What's even more interesting is that, if you think there's a business case for Canadian LNG, you need others to be willing to pay a lot more per GJ than we are paying today. At least $5/GJ more. That's how much the ctax will go up by 2030, and it seems economies would collapse. pic.twitter.com/iNyOSMcZsj
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) September 16, 2024
I will also add that it was incredibly disappointing that in writing up the story, The Canadian Press simply both-sidesed Poilievre’s nonsense with the talking points of the two other parties, instead of phoning up an economist who could say “That’s horseshit, you should stop listening to that man.” (Yes, it was a Sunday, but a service like CP should have enough contacts that someone would answer their phones who is NOT Ian Lee). But leaving Poilievre’s comments to stand like that, completely unchallenged, is irresponsible.
Meanwhile, as the Liberals try yet another round of trying to convince the public of the merits of the carbon levy and that the rebates exist, there have been a few suggestions of what they should have done from the start, but Jennifer Robson’s are among the most salient/best to implement.
1) If you’re gonna’ mail anything, mail a one page, clean but eye-catching, personalized statement of benefits. Here’s what YOU are getting all year and here are the dates & amounts of each payment. Include CCB, CWB, GST rebate if you want.
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) September 15, 2024
https://twitter.com/JenniferRobson8/status/1835333573366210734
But while CRA administers the rebates, Environment has more policy skin in the game. Their ad budget was just $6m last fiscal.
CRA’s approach on comms is all about responding when people initiate (call centres, chatbots, ++). They aren’t the right team to lead on this.
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) September 15, 2024
Maybe we don’t need citizens to understand the nuances of the consumer carbon price.
Maybe it’s enough to have them want to keep the up to $2k cash (for fam of 4 in rural AB: https://t.co/qktdrlfBUx) the policy generates. pic.twitter.com/2ImzocU9sI
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) September 15, 2024
Ukraine Dispatch
A married couple were killed in a Russian strike on the suburbs of Odesa, while at least 42 were injured in an air strike on an apartment building in Kharkiv. There was another prisoner exchange over the weekend, swapping 103 POWs from each side.
This week, the Russians have launched around 30 missiles of various types, more than 800 guided aerial bombs, and nearly 300 strike drones against Ukraine.
Ukraine needs strong support from our partners to defend lives against Russian terror—air defense, long-range capabilities,… pic.twitter.com/G51XjQpbem
— Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) September 15, 2024
⚡️Air defense repels mass drone attack against Kyiv.
Air defense forces intercepted "almost two dozen" Russian drones over the city's airspace. There were no casualties or damage in Kyiv as a result of the attack, according to preliminary reports.https://t.co/mGtrUGrHSZ
— The Kyiv Independent (@KyivIndependent) September 16, 2024
Good reads:
- Today is the day for the by-elections in LaSalle—Émard—Verdun and Elmwood—Transcona, and they are naturally being portrayed as major tests.
- François-Philippe Champagne is dismissing Elon Musk’s claim he could connect more Canadians for cheaper than the Telesat deal as “nonsense.”
- The Emir of Qatar will be visiting Ottawa this week.
- Air Canada and its pilots’ union have come to a deal to avoid a strike.
- While the tech bros say that their “AI” tools can’t be used for political disinformation, nearly all companies failed when put to the test.
- Here is a deeper look into Russian disinformation posing as legitimate Canadian news in Canada, pushing Poilievre in an attempt to polarise the discourse.
- No return to Parliament would be complete without a look at where the leaders travelled over the summer and divining what it all means.
- At the Liberal caucus retreat, one of the campaign co-chairs told MPs to “change their attitudes,” which didn’t go over well with the majority of them.
- David Eby is now promising “involuntary treatment” for people with mental health and addictions, and I fail to see how this is remotely constitutional.
- Kevin Carmichael makes the case for Mark Carney as having the ability to help Canada get past this moment of economic malaise.
- Shannon Proudfoot suggests that civil service unions actually listen to what they sound like and why they are out of step with the rest of Canadian society.
- Althia Raj hears from Liberals about Trudeau’s decision to be “unshackled” as part of his refreshed comms plan over the year ahead.
- My weekend column looks at how Jagmeet Singh shredded the last vestiges of his credibility with his decision to rely on magical thinking for a climate plan.
Odds and ends:
Can one oppose a non-existent plan? And yes, I am fond of a plan I helped design (originally for an NDP government in Alberta). Glad to see the NDP joining another PP trope with the "expert" business though. He really has found affordable housing in all of your heads. https://t.co/posSxVVsGC
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) September 14, 2024
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.
CRA doesn’t respond to communications you initiate! Its impenetrable. Having said that, the Trudeau government made some positive changes to the tax form that I notice whenever I file.
I would miss the carbon price rebate. But I don’t understand why it took so long to get the amount documented. I get a notice every year about the gst refund. In the old days there was a “baby bonus.” The carbon rebate is now identified on my bank statement, but it’s baffling why banks had to be pushed to do that.
Can we lay it at Catherine McKenna’s door? It’s not a reach to see her as someone who overlooked something as mundane as finding a label for the rebate as compelling as “baby bonus”.