Roundup: Another useless vote-a-thon over

Posted on by

After about thirty hours, the vote-a-thon “filibuster” was complete (it wasn’t a filibuster), and MPs went home. Well, probably not home, as they all missed their flights, so a bunch will either be trying for a weekend flight only to turn around and fly back 24 hours later, or they’ll stay in Ottawa for the weekend, and fume about missing family and constituency events, and it’ll be Conservatives fuming as much, if not more so than anyone else. It bears noting that Justin Trudeau was present for much of the voting in person, and most of his front bench was as well—François-Philippe Champagne arrived directly from his flight from Dubai and immediately headed to the Chamber to vote, with some jokes that he didn’t know what time it was supposed to be after the flight. Pierre Poilievre, on the other hand, was absent for nearly all of it. After taking off for a Hannukah event in Montreal (there is a whole sub-plot of Conservative MPs going to Hannukah events where Liberals didn’t because these were confidence votes on a money bill) and then a fundraiser, he arrived late in the night bearing fast food, tried to move a motion to end the vote-a-thon if the Liberals would accede to his demands and “axe the tax,” which they wouldn’t, and then he took off again and was mostly absent the rest of the vote-a-thon. Because he’s a leader like that. (Coverage of the votes from The Canadian Press, CBC, the Star and the National Post, each making different observations).

This vote-a-thon technique has been done before, and it’s failed before, because it never connects to whatever the Conservatives are demanding. They are merely exploiting the fact that for Supply, they can engineer to vote on individual line-items, so they force these vote-a-thons as some sort of “punishment” for the Liberals, but this has all of the same logic as being mad at your partner and withholding sex. The end result is that you really only end up punishing yourself. The Liberals treated this as a big team-building exercise at a time of great caucus unrest and division, and according to all of the reports, morale was high throughout, while Poilievre is going to be hearing about this from his angry backbenchers. Not to mention, the whole logic of thinking that the minor discomfort of a thirty-hour vote-a-thon is going to force the Liberals to abandon a signature policy that they won three elections on and is supported by every other party in the Chamber is ludicrous. That the Conservatives are trying to spin this as a pressure tactic is risible.

And spin is what they are indeed trying to do. Scheer tried to spin this as a “victory” because they made the House lose a sitting day, even though that was a Friday, so not very many hours of debate were really lost. Poilievre has since been insisting that he’s going to prevent the government from going “on holidays,” but he has no power to do that. The Standing Orders have a fixed date to rise, and changing that would require a unanimous consent motion, which he’s never going to get. This was just an impotent exercise in wasting everyone’s time for a temper tantrum based on the lie that carbon pricing is what is driving unaffordability (that has been debunked so many times), but these are the times we live in, where this is all for performance and clips—which the Liberals have been making their own of, where Conservatives voted against line items about the very things they claim to care about, and in particular things like NATO exercises and support for Ukraine—votes that will be going into dossiers in the capitals of our allies, as they know just who Poilievre will be should he ever form government.

Ukraine Dispatch:

Russians conducted missile strikes against the central part of Ukraine, with 14 missiles shot down outside of Kyiv and Dnipropetrovsk, while they again pressed the attack at Avdiivka and Kupiansk. Media were invited to see Ukrainian troops training for winter combat at facilities in Poland. Here is a look at the attempt to get better casualty figures for the war, particularly from the Ukrainian side, where they aren’t published for fear of harming the war effort.

https://twitter.com/ukraine_world/status/1733078163360477582

Good reads:

  • In June, Mélanie Joly promised more language training for diplomats, and two months later, the department cut two programmes, citing budget pressures.
  • CSIS Director David Vigneault apologised to staff for his response to the media accounts of sexual assaults suffered by employees on the job. (Transcript here).
  • At a CIGI event, National Security Advisor Jody Thomas delivered a bleak assessment of the threat of AI-powered disinformation campaigns.
  • CBC president Catherine Tait says that they will look at “all possible measures” including executive compensation and bonuses to relieve their financial pressure.
  • The Supreme Court of Canada ruled that the Northwest Territories was wrong to refuse “non-rights-holders” the opportunity to learn French in schools.
  • The Court also ruled from the bench around jury instructions in a criminal trial (and you can see the video of the decision here).
  • The vice-president of Sun Life apologised at a Government Operations committee meeting for the chaos of transitioning civil servants over to their benefits program.
  • The Fisheries committee has been hearing about the illegal poaching of elvers in Nova Scotia, where one Conservative MP claimed he got death threats over it.

Odds and ends:

I contributed to this Reuters piece on the vote-a-thon.

Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.

One thought on “Roundup: Another useless vote-a-thon over”

  1. I did a little survey while Xmas shopping yesterday. Four out of five asked if they were going to vote for Polly and his party said no, the fifth said she hated Trudeau but was scared of Polly. He has time to trick and lie his way to defeat. Canadians are not stupid enough to see him as PM and Canada is not broken.

Comments are closed.