Not satisfied with his plan to break federal laws in not remitting the carbon levy for natural gas, Scott Moe decided that he was going to ramp it up by also not collecting it for electric heating, which is going to be a neat trick when it comes to trying to disaggregating it from regular electricity use. He says they’re going to find out how many homes us it and reduce the levy collection by a formula that approximates what it might be, but it’s still ridiculous and is just more of this very bad trend of premiers who think that they can just get away with violating federal law if they feel like it. But it’s not him that’ll be exposed by this—it’s the CEO and board of SaskPower, just like with SaskEnergy, and they’re the ones exposed to criminal liability for breaking federal law, not Moe, and that should be of concern to anyone in these positions.
There is no carbon levy on electric heat. The carbon levy applies to Sask Power and, if the Premier would like to fund that with tax dollars, he is of course free to do so. Otherwise, we're back to "pistols at dawn, PM Trudeau. You and Rupen Pandya. Good luck." https://t.co/pyCrrtaAzl
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 30, 2023
The fun detail is that, in this case, the federal government recently approved SK's own industrial carbon emissions pricing system. So, is Moe exempting electricity from that program? Or is he just telling SaskPower not to flow it through to bills? https://t.co/5x7TLFc0lk
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 30, 2023
The reason Saskatchewan was exempted from Part II of the GGPPA was that they proposed a domestic carbon pricing system that would apply to all industrial emitters including SaskPower. If they're exempting SaskPower, that federal exemption will be gone. https://t.co/Jdcrf3RwwF
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 30, 2023
Of course, it bears repeating that it’s not the carbon price driving up these costs, really—it’s the utility provider. But that won’t stop Moe and the federal Conservatives from lying about the size and effect of carbon prices as a distraction (or legacy media from not calling it out).
Something I just learned today: SaskPower customers are paying 15.1c/kWh for electricity, with 1.1c/kWh of that being carbon charges. The other 14c raises a lot of questions given the supposed cheap cost cost coal and gas power…
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 30, 2023
Electron Jane here is paying less than $5 in carbon charges to the *SK government*, and she's paying an average cost of 20.4c per kWh for delivered electricity to Sask Power. She's also paying a 10% municipal surcharge. And those Sask Power rates? Up 8% over the last two years. pic.twitter.com/MW8hup9ZPK
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 30, 2023
Ukraine Dispatch:
Russian missiles struck three towns in Eastern Ukraine—Pokrovsk, Novohrodivka, and Myronhrad, killing two and wounding ten. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy visited troops on the northeast frontlines, and called for the faster construction of fortifications in key areas under threat from Russian forces.
The frontline command post of Kupyansk defenders. It was an honor to meet and award the warriors.
The fighters on the Kupyansk front are defending the peaceful life of Ukrainians, the people of Kharkiv region. I thank the warriors for their service, for defending our state! I… pic.twitter.com/pq4QdGXBNP
— Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) November 30, 2023
⚡️Russian attacks on Donetsk, Kherson oblasts kill 3, injure 12.
Russian forces struck multiple settlements in Kherson and Donetsk oblasts on Nov. 30, killing three people and wounding another 12, the regional authorities reported. https://t.co/0WPqh2v8t1
— The Kyiv Independent (@KyivIndependent) November 30, 2023
Good reads:
- Justin Trudeau says that reports that CSIS agents were sexually assaulted on the job by senior colleagues are “devastating” and “absolutely unacceptable.”
- Arif Virani says that he will accept Senate amendments on the bail reform bill.
- The federal government has decided to go ahead with a sole-source contract for Boeing P-8As for new surveillance aircraft because no other suitable planes exist.
- Gary Anandasangaree says the Métis self-government bill would help right past wrongs, in spite of objections raised by numerous First Nations groups.
- Pascal St-Onge is hinting that she may limit how much money CBC qualifies for under the deal with Google, given they are already publicly funded.
- The deputy minister of Canadian Heritage says that the government has taken legal action to recoup anti-racism funds given to Laith Marouf.
- A national 988 suicide prevention helpline went into operation yesterday.
- Two former CSIS directors point out that the assassination plot indictment in the US vindicates what Trudeau said about India all along.
- An internal RCMP report shows that Cameron Ortis was demonstrating suspicious behaviour which was ignored because of assumptions made about trustworthiness.
- NSIRA says that CBSA needs to do a better job of documenting why certain air passengers need extra screening upon arrival.
- A group of Ontario First Nations chiefs has launched a court challenge against the carbon price.
- In case you missed this week’s “Is Christmas racist?” stupidity, here is all of the background on what this non-issue is really about.
- Experts whom the government previously consulted with on the proposed online harms bill are calling on them to get moving on introducing the bill.
- The Commons health committee is calling for a national registry of breast implants so that they can track problems with them.
- Conservative MP Rachael Thomas has sort-of apologised for demanding that Pascale St-Onge respond in English at committee (because she wanted clips).
- Althia Raj reiterates the point that the Rachael Thomas incident at committee was only about getting clips, which is the problem with Parliament these days.
- Paul Wells has a conversation with the head of the Royal Canadian Navy following a frank video he put out about the operational readiness of our marine forces.
- My Xtra column looks at the ties between Canadian Conservatives and the Danube Institute spreading Orbánism and “illiberal democracy” around Western countries.
Odds and ends:
You know that “globalist” is an antisemitic dogwhistle, right? pic.twitter.com/yKg9ii13cY
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) November 30, 2023
Looking to get a copy of my book #UnbrokenMachine? Get it directly from @dundurnpress for 25% off, using code HOLIDAY23. https://t.co/VLoITR00fP
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) November 21, 2023
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.