Because everything is stupid, it would seem that Pierre Poilievre is endorsing Scott Moe’s plan to break federal law and not collect the federal carbon price on natural gas. Or, well, instruct his Crown corporation to break the law and not collect or remit it, which puts them in legal jeopardy, which they’re frankly not going to do. But this is what happens when politics has been reduced to performative nonsense and doing stupid things to “own the Libs.” If only we still had grown-ups involved…
I honestly can't believe @PierrePoilievre is endorsing Scott Moe attempting to compel a Crown Corp to break federal law. Law and order for thee but not not for me.
(NB an order to compel a Crown Agency to break federal law is either invalid or inoperative. It won't fly.) pic.twitter.com/OP0CLAsHFp
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 12, 2023
The GGPPA imposes a requirement on the officers of SaskEnergy, and criminal law penalties apply to those officers who would withhold fuel charge payments. Scott Moe is putting SaskEnergy in legal jeopardy. Luckily, their counsel will know Sask law won'tbe operative.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 12, 2023
Perhaps it could be like Manitoba Egg. Pass a law identical to one you don't like in another province, refer it to the BCCA for a constitutional reference, lose, appeal to scc, lose, and SCC can let us know whether such laws are invalid or merely inoperative.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 12, 2023
In this context, it seems that Mr Poilievre was not as supportive of provincial jurisdiction and the capacity for Premiers to obstruct valid federal law. Double standard? Definitely. https://t.co/Y9haLnTk4X
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 12, 2023
Oh, and for those of you asking, the “pause” on the carbon price on home heating oil doesn’t invalidate the whole scheme, as there were already carve-outs when it came into existence. Try again.
There is a significant misconception that the scc decision implied that the carbon price needed to be applied on all emissions at all times to be valid. No. In fact, the legislation as challenged had major exemptions that favoured some provinces over others. 1/
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 12, 2023
There are also exemptions for fishing fuels, an undoubtedly regional exemption benefitting the Atlantic provinces and BC more than other regions. I'm no fan of the temporary heating oil carve out, but don't make up law to suit your anger. 3/
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) November 12, 2023
Ukraine Dispatch:
Ukrainian intelligence says that three Russian officers were killed in a blast by local resistance groups in occupied Melitopol. Russians targeted Kyiv overnight on Saturday, and killed four people in strikes on Kherson, Dnipropetrovsk, and Zaporizhzhia, while pro-Ukrainian saboteurs derailed a train in Russia with an improvised explosive device.
On this day a year ago, the Ukrainian flag returned to Kherson.
We all have vivid memories of these emotions. How people greeted our soldiers, how adults and children celebrated. Thank you to every warrior who made this possible. We remember everyone who gave their lives for the… pic.twitter.com/zcoGKPCHYA
— Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) November 11, 2023
Today the Russian army launched a missile attack on #Kherson: the library was hit, a fire broke out there.
While extinguishing a fire in a library, the 🇷🇺 military struck again. Rescuers had to return to the fire several times.
– Oblast Military Administration
📷: SES pic.twitter.com/XlTAwIxFtw— UkraineWorld (@ukraine_world) November 12, 2023
Good reads:
- Here are some quotes from Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre, and others, on the occasion of Remembrance Day.
- Global Affairs says that 234 Canadians, permanent residents and their family members were able to leave Gaza on Sunday.
- The path to our emissions targets will mean steeper reductions in the oil and gas sector, which the sector’s apologists and greenwashers are balking at.
- The president and CEO of Sustainable Development Technologies Canada has stepped down, while the chair continues to defend the organisation.
- Here is a look at how Canadians have a tendency not to talk about our military history in a meaningful way, letting it fade away.
- CBC looks into the dichotomy between solar farms and agricultural land, and whether there is a genuine conflict between the two.
- A $55-million deal has been reached around legal fees for the $23-billion class action settlement for First Nations children taken into care.
- Kevin Carmichael ponders the era of “structural uncertainty” that we appear to be entering into and how that translates for businesses.
- Patricia Treble looks behind-the-scenes at Sophie, Duchess of Edinburgh’s recent visit to Toronto and area, and the preparation for these private working tours.
- Susan Delacourt wonders, somewhat rhetorically, why our political leaders aren’t trying to unite the country over the Israel-Hamas conflict.
Odds and ends:
The Ottawa Citizen’s “We Are the Dead” project was for Private Emile Matthé of Montreal, who enlisted for the First World War.
New episodes released early for C$7+ subscribers. This week I talk about the premiers whining they’re not getting housing dollars. #cdnpoli https://t.co/pKDDx2Gd8I
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) November 13, 2023
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.