The supposed “1 Million March 4 Children” took place yesterday in cities across Canada, and in most instances, were drowned out by counter-protesters—a welcome sign to be sure. And to be clear, these protests have nothing to do with children, or “parental rights,” but is focused largely on the moral panic around trans rights (and the falsehood that they are mutilating and sterilising children), pronoun policies in schools, and the libel that this is somehow about gays “grooming” children, or indoctrinating them to be gay. The attendees are pretty much a toxic brew of leftover “Freedom Convoy” enthusiasts, grievance tourists, far-right nationals, and some Muslim parents whom they have temporary found common cause with (and don’t expect this to last, given that much of the far-right agitation in Canada has its roots in Islamophobia, but they’re happy to let the Muslims agitate against LGBTQ+ people on their behalf). A few arrests were made at some of the demonstrations, but they were largely peaceful in that regard. (Write-up of the Ottawa event here, with photos here).
Big crowds marched up to the Hill to protest against the attacks on trans persons. I’m committed to standing up for the human rights of all persons. #TransRightsAreHumanRights pic.twitter.com/BY3mbagoXI
— Artur Wilczynski (@Arturmaks) September 20, 2023
If nothing else, a big takeaway from the day is that despite weeks and weeks of planning, organizing, coordinating, and feeding off each other's paranoia and rage, the turnout was laughable.
Just because people are extremely loud online doesn't mean they represent the real world.— Alheli Picazo (@a_picazo) September 21, 2023
The hate marchers were FIXATED on equating LGBTQ2S identity with 'grooming'- but teaching someone who is vulnerable that they are your property is one of the most damaging and powerful grooming tactics that are used on abused children & adults
— Dr. Ardath Whynacht (@ArdathJean) September 20, 2023
When you hate gay people but can't say the quiet part out loud pic.twitter.com/BQrv0dACLQ
— Trevor Robb (@TrevorRobb_) September 20, 2023
In terms of political reaction, the marchers didn’t get much support, outside of New Brunswick premier Blaine Higgs who greeted them and made common cause with them, because of course he did. In Ottawa, Jagmeet Singh led a counter-protest march, while the Conservatives were instructed to steer clear and say nothing, not even when it was raised in Question Period, as they sat stone-faced when others clapped about the denunciation of anti-trans hate. This silence is of course deliberate—it’s not because of a lack of conviction, but because they don’t want to jeopardise any ability to try and eat into the PPC’s far-right voter base, because that’s how they think they’ll edge out the Liberals in the next election. And I really have to question how MPs like Melissa Lantsman and Eric Duncan can sit there through this as though this doesn’t affect them (because remember, there is not “good parts only” version of right-wing populism. You can’t try and dog-whistle about “gender theory” and think that it’ll stop there, because it won’t).
StOp NoRmAlIzInG SeX aNd NuDiTy.
Good grief.
So many people have whipped themselves into outrage over imagined realities.
The nonsense flooding social media is poisoning minds and driving so much hysteria. #cdnpoli https://t.co/Te8jlYXNcy
— Alheli Picazo (@a_picazo) September 20, 2023
The thing that gets me through all of this so-called movement to “protect children” is this insistence that LGBTQ+ people must be “grooming” children or indoctrinating them because there’s this belief that they’re too young to know if they’re gay or lesbian, or even trans. In most cases, that’s not true—most kids know who they are, and most of us older LGBTQ+ people have been through miserable and unsupportive youth and adolescence, and want to ensure that the next generation doesn’t have to go through what we did. That these people are masking their homophobia and transphobia as concern is one thing, but it’s the complete lack of empathy on their part that really gets me.
I’m the parent of a kid who changed their pronouns and first name at school without consulting me.
Ask me anything, but be respectful.
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) September 21, 2023
Ukraine Dispatch:
Russians conducted strikes in at least six cities, including Kyiv, Kherson, Kharkiv, Cherkasy, and Lviv. AP has a look inside a Ukrainian platoon that freed Andriivka. At the UN, president Volodymyr Zelenskyy addressed the Security Council about Russia breaking the UN Charter.
https://twitter.com/ukraine_world/status/1704473607273881853
Looks like someone has lost a submarine in a land war. pic.twitter.com/XnV1A3AUwy
— Defense of Ukraine (@DefenceU) September 20, 2023
Good reads:
- Justin Trudeau told a climate event at the UN General Assembly that Canada is on track to exceed its methane reduction targets (but we did expand our fossil fuels).
- As Trudeau has been having pull-aside meetings at the UN, Australia’s foreign minister calls the allegations about Indian agents “credible.”
- Mélanie Joly relayed Canada’s “grave concerns” about Azerbaijan escalating military action in the Nagorno-Karabakh region involving Armenians.
- Canada will pull some of its diplomatic staff from India following recent threats.
- The Privacy Commissioner says Canada Post broke the law by harvesting information from envelopes and packages.
- The Ombudsman for Responsible Enterprise is investigating Levi Strauss for possible forced labour in their supply chain.
- Indian officials have suddenly started claiming students in Canada face risks to their personal safety, undermining their own High Commissioner’s comments.
- American politicians are warning Canada against implementing a possible digital services tax on web giants (which we won’t do if the OECD gets its act together).
- A group of senators are calling on the government to institute stricter criteria for schools that host international students.
- Senator Jim Quinn introduced a bill to make the isthmus between New Brunswick and Nova Scotia federal jurisdiction (but that is a money bill and illegitimate).
- Here is a look at Senator Marilou McPhedran’s outsized Senate expenses (which includes some journalistic malpractice, like getting quotes from the CTF).
- Liberals from Atlantic Canada are calling out Conservative opposition to a bill that would extend the Atlantic Accords to include renewable energy such as wind farms.
- Pierre Poilievre tabled his housing bill, which I’m dubious will even be voteable.
- The Centre Ice Conservatives/Canadians group is calling their new political party “Canadian Future” (which is almost certainly a doomed venture).
- A second Doug Ford minister, Kaleed Rasheed, resigned from Cabinet and stepped away from caucus over a trip to Vegas with Greenbelt Developers and lying about it.
- Paul Wells pays a visit to Hamilton East Stoney Creek after the poll numbers look to be shifting there, and talks to the putative Conservative candidate about the mood.
Odds and ends:
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.