The Commons’ government operations committee met and, as expected, launched a study into those McKinsey contracts, but because the Liberals decided to be tricksey about it, they got consent to amend the terms so they’re going to review contracts going back to 2011, which means they’ll also be reviewing Conservative-era contracts. But it’s all pretty stupid because McKinsey does very little in the way of government contracts overall (especially compared to a number of other big firms), and this is just about politics and the Conservatives trying to accuse McKinsey of being a “Liberal-friendly firm” because of Dominic Barton, not to mention the fact that McKinsey has had a lot of bad press of late. But this doesn’t touch the overall issue of use of outside consultants by government, and is mostly going to be about showboating, because why do actual valuable work in committee when you can spend all of your time scoring partisan points.
Now in wide release, my latest YouTube episode, where @JenniferRobson8 and I discuss the so-called “Shadow Public Service,” and put the use of consultants by government into some context #cdnpoli https://t.co/wI2yDrjV0Z
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) January 18, 2023
With that in mind, I will point you to my most recent YouTube episode, where Carleton university professor Jennifer Robson and I discuss the rise of the so-called “shadow public service,” and it’s a lot more nuanced than you think. Additional context from Robson below:
Total federal PS employment was 319K as of Mar '22. That's up 11% since Mar '17. Yes, biggest growth has been in 'casual' employees (up 24%) but these still account for a tiny share (9K or 3%) of total PS workforce.
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) January 16, 2023
As I mentioned to Dale, it's actually REALLY hard for PS managers to hire. Here's an illustration for one of the most populous federal departments (ESDC) : 216 days and that's for *internal* candidates, people already inside the system. Source: https://t.co/ddYYZIXcDI pic.twitter.com/R9T93KYzlC
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) January 16, 2023
But what about contracts to big firms, especially multinationals like McKinsey? Those contracts generally show up under spending on professional services unless goods are involved (like IM/IT solutions) when it's likely capital/procurement.
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) January 16, 2023
All contracts over $10K must be reported on GoC open data site here: https://t.co/HsmMCDTJjv You can see 'tombstone' info. and additional records (SoW, deliverables, +++) can be asked for under ATIP (yes, it's broken).
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) January 16, 2023
3) It's worth asking questions about value for money in make/buy decisions for work of government, but with honest accounting of full costs & benefits.
Source for federal HR & spending: https://t.co/yi0Op9i0Ge
— Dr. J Robson (@JenniferRobson8) January 16, 2023
Ukraine Dispatch, Day 330:
The major news out of Ukraine was a helicopter crash, killing the country’s interior minister, senior staffers, and one child when it crashed into a kindergarten in a suburb of Kyiv. What we know and don’t know about the crash can be found here, but there is no indication yet if it was downed by Russian missiles. Meanwhile, the International Atomic Energy Agency is placing teams in all four of Ukraine’s nuclear power plants to reduce the risk of accidents as the fighting carries on.
https://twitter.com/zelenskyyua/status/1615719966820507684
Good reads:
- Justin Trudeau spent the day in Shawinigan, Quebec.
- Anita Anand was in Kyiv to announce that Canada will be sending another 200 armoured personnel carriers to Ukraine (but no word yet on tanks).
- The RCMP say they’re going to keep using neck holds in spite of ministerial directives not to, and can we just dismantle them already?
- The Canadian Press fact-checks Poilievre’s statements about the need for bail reform, and it shouldn’t surprise you that he’s wrong about all of it.
- Jagmeet Singh says the Liberals are “waging war against the working class” and threatening public healthcare. Gosh, if only someone wasn’t propping them up.
- Both Ontario’s integrity commissioner and its auditor general will look into Doug Ford’s Greenbelt development plan in separate investigations.
- BC has signed a land, water and resource management agreement with a First Nation in the north-eastern part of the province.
Odds and ends:
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.