With all of the tongue-wagging in Parliament over Joël Lightbound going rogue in his dissent on vaccine mandates, there have been a lot of questions about his place in caucus, and what the other caucus “rebels” think of the situation. So, the most famous of said rebels, Nathaniel Erskine-Smith, tweeted a thoughtful thread on the subject.
First, I respect Joel a great deal and I'm glad he's a colleague of mine. It's probably obvious enough for those who know me, but I also think greater independence in our politics should be embraced. /2
— Nate Erskine-Smith (@beynate) February 10, 2022
He's right that we all need to stand down on divisive rhetoric. No, the Prime Minister is not the greatest threat to freedom in this country. Yes, unvaccinated Canadians are our neighbours and we should meet those with whom we disagree with compassion. /4
— Nate Erskine-Smith (@beynate) February 10, 2022
Two related digressions:
1) it's maddening that Joel's call for less divisive rhetoric is being used by the CPC to attack and divide.
2) lines must still be drawn and we should not platform or engage the language of treason, medical experiments, Nuremberg Code, etc. /6
— Nate Erskine-Smith (@beynate) February 10, 2022
Now, there was also much I disagreed with in Joel's presentation.
First, he unfortunately blended federal and provincial rules, adding to confusion. Capacity restrictions, school closures, lockdowns – these are all provincial, and any criticisms should set the right target. /8
— Nate Erskine-Smith (@beynate) February 10, 2022
Lastly, any serious criticism of government rules should acknowledge that mandates and restrictions are very different interventions. Restrictions are damaging to many aspects of our society. Mandates help to increase vaccination rates and they prevent future restrictions. /10
— Nate Erskine-Smith (@beynate) February 10, 2022
Meanwhile, a third Liberal was thought to be joining Lightbound and Yves Robillard in their dissent, but it turns out that no, that they merely misrepresented Anthony Housefather’s position. So there’s that.
I was pleased to speak in the House tonight to set out my views. As I’ve always said, I believe all governments should communicate their plans related to public health restrictions & explain when & how they will evolve. I do not agree all mandates & restrictions should end now.
— Anthony Housefather (@AHousefather) February 11, 2022
Grifter Occupation: Day 15
There was minor progress yesterday, as one intersection outside of the official occupation zone was cleared, and police are apparently handing out more tickets, but the occupation nevertheless grinds on, while some of its denizens tried to escalate matters by circling the airport with their trucks, or jamming 911 lines, and threats of “protesting” outside of schools.
Okay, so police have made substantial progress at Bank and Laurier. One side had been fully blocked in by semis and other trucks, but it’s clear around here right now. Police tweeted earlier they got 10 trucks to leave this area (unclear where they went.) pic.twitter.com/kU4S1VRKeI
— Brian Platt (@btaplatt) February 10, 2022
The embodiment of white privilege comparing himself to Rosa Parks is just a perfect encapsulation of the combined victim/martyr complex of these grievance tourists. #cdnpoli pic.twitter.com/4AZQTqXz1I
— Alheli Picazo (@a_picazo) February 10, 2022
The prime minister bowed to pressure from the opposition leaders and gave them a briefing, after he had a meeting of the Federal Incident Response Group and calls with premiers (many of whom are not doing their jobs). It was noted that the Conservatives changed their tune inside of the House of Commons by saying it was time for the occupiers to go home—but at the very same time, they spent the day debating a Supply Day motion that essentially called on the government to capitulate to their demands by ending all federal vaccine mandates. Because what we really want is to teach an angry mob that all you need to do to force a government’s hand is to start blockading ports of entry and Ottawa’s downtown. Such strategic genius!
I mean seriously, believing that people deliberately blocking a land border for days on end didn't mean to cause economic disruption ? How far up your ass does your head have to be to hold those two ideas compatible?
— Alex Usher (@AlexUsherHESA) February 11, 2022
After ignoring another meeting at the ministerial level, Doug Ford did announce that they would invoke a section of the Criminal Code to prevent the occupiers at either Ontario site from accessing the crowd-sourced funds they have raised, which I suspect will just push more donors to the organiser’s personal email transfer (because that’s not a red flag for grift), while other organisers are trying to push donations into crypto (again, grift). But there is a lot of active misinformation circulating among the occupied zone (aided by a former Trump official) and the reliance on conspiracy theories and outright delusion is merely emboldening them, which likely means that this is likely to carry on for a while longer still. Oh boy.
https://twitter.com/DavidWCochrane/status/1491799241559216144
Speaker out this afternoon says it’s only a “matter of time” before Parliament and law enforcement “stand down and they stand with us.”
Touts the participation of two Conservative MPs and cites Liberals speaking out. #cdnpoli #truckerconvoy2022 pic.twitter.com/tSGbcsKPiE
— Rachel Aiello (@rachaiello) February 10, 2022
Subtweeting the Ottawa Police. https://t.co/B2uSf8YNor
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) February 10, 2022
Good reads:
- National Defence underspent by $1.2 billion last year, largely in delayed capital projects like ships.
- Unsurprisingly, the Correctional Investigator found that Black and Indigenous inmates faced disproportionate uses of force against them in prisons.
- FINTRAC told the Commons public safety committee that they don’t track crowdfunding sites like GoFundMe.
- A group of former federal and provincial conservatives have launched a group called Conservatives for Clean Growth. (We’ll see how much uptake they get).
- New Brunswick is trying to use their provincial emergency powers to head off any attempted convoy protests in that province.
- Matt Gurney wants to see leadership on the occupations and blockades, and is particularly outraged that Ontario isn’t even bothering to show up to meetings.
- Robert Hiltz points out the absurdity that the most sustained anger we’re seeing with the grifter occupation is that governments did too much in the pandemic.
Odds and ends:
— Dale Smith (@journo_dale) February 11, 2022
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.
Clearly, Lightbound got under Erskine-Smith’s skin to the point that E-S thought the only effective counter was to misrepresent his colleague’s remarks.
Lightbound came nowhere close to implying that the Prime Minister was “the greatest threat to freedom in this country.” What he actually said was: “I can’t help but notice, with regret, that both the tone and the policies of my government changed drastically on the eve and during the last election campaign. From a positive and unifying approach, a decision was made to wedge, to divide, and to stigmatize. I fear that this politicization of the pandemic risks undermining the public’s trust in our public health institutions. This is not a risk we ought to be taking lightly.”
If E-S can provide a truthful counter to Lightbound’s message, he should do so. If he can’t, then he shouldn’t invent words that Lightbound never used in a juvenile effort to discredit the messenger.
No, that was a quote from Andrew Scheer. E-S was using it as an example of divisive language being deployed around vaccines.