It was Throne Speech day in Alberta, and sure enough, it contained an ambitious laundry list of upcoming legislation designed to undo much of what the NDP had put into place as a means of “restoring” the mythical Alberta Advantage. (Full speech here). Shortly thereafter, the promised Bill 1 to repeal the province’s carbon levy was introduced – pretty much guaranteeing that the federal carbon price will be imposed once the bill is enacted. It doesn’t repeal all of the carbon prices in the province, however – it merely shifts them to the largest polluters, which does nothing about the demand side of carbon consumption, and won’t shift consumer behaviours, nor will it do enough for those large emitters, because for all of Kenney’s talk about looking to protect the energy sector, he just shifted the bulk of the burden onto them. (It also won’t really help consumers because poorer households will be worse off now).
Meanwhile, here’s Andrew Leach to explain why Kenney’s repeal of the carbon price is handing a rhetorical victory to Ontario, and why the reliance on magical technology from the future to reduce emissions won’t happen if there aren’t proper price signals to spur its development.
Today, Alberta's government will introduce a bill which significantly reduces the stringency of our actions on climate change, reduces the value of GHG-reducing innovations and places the burden of meeting our GHG reduction goals solely on our largest emitters. #cdnpoli #ableg pic.twitter.com/EuD5AkB9nE
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) May 22, 2019
The Alberta that I've known for more than a decade would have stood up to an Ontario Premier who said the problem was (AB) polluters not commuters, and who looked at this graph and said, "I see where the problem is." Today, @jkenney will agree with a Premier saying that. #ableg pic.twitter.com/5rbVr3LMi2
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) May 22, 2019
Do you know why those commitments weren't met? It wasn't because tech didn't materialize – it's because those commitments were projections of what would happen under a stringent set of policies – policies which were never implemented. Technology deployment doesn't just happen.
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) May 22, 2019
Over the next few days, you'll hear about how technology will solve the problem from those introducing legislation which reduces by 1/3 the value of emissions-reducing innovation in large industrial sectors and destroys any value it would have had outside those sectors. #ableg
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) May 22, 2019
I really hope that the most ambitious views on oil sands tech are valid, and not just because the Premier's about to make a big bet on that. Enjoy the throne speech, Alberta. Then get ready to have your resource industry back as the climate change focal point. #ableg #cdnpoli
— Andrew Leach (@andrew_leach) May 22, 2019
Will "cancelling the CTax" offer $1.4 billion in tax relief to Albertans? No.
The CTax does raise $1.38B in 2019/20, but $530m of refundable tax credits are cancelled. So, the net effect is less than the headline number.
— Trevor Tombe (@trevortombe) May 22, 2019
Good reads:
- Justin Trudeau announced a $15.7 billion plan for new Coast Guard ships involving all three major shipyards, which pretty much makes the established plan moot.
- In what is now commonplace, Trudeau was heckled by protesters during a fundraiser speech while in Vancouver.
- The government has hired a company to deal with the garbage situation in the Philippines, as their president ups his rhetoric.
- Pablo Rodriguez announced the composition of the panel who will advise on the newspaper bailout, and it is all journalism associations and unions, including Unifor.
- The Chief of Defence Staff admits to not handling the Kandahar memorial issue properly as families of those fallen soldiers are objecting to being shut out.
- Here’s a longread on the RCMP’s attempt to remove members of the Force who have disabilities, and their fight to keep their jobs.
- Two historians explain the significance of the federal government decision to exonerate Chief Poundmaker after the Northwest Rebellion.
- StatsCan released a survey on the state of sexual misconduct in the military, and the numbers have not been changing significantly since Operation Honour began.
- The former BC Liberal health minister, Terry Lake, has come out of retirement to run for the federal Liberals in the fall election.
- Andrew Scheer promised to get tough on human trafficking, largely via the Criminal Code (rather than things like reducing the poverty that makes people vulnerable)
- One-time Conservative Cabinet minister Stephen Fletcher (currently an independent Manitoba MLA) has decided to run for Maxime Bernier’s party.
- Kevin Carmichael points out all of the things in the IMF’s preliminary report card on Canada’s economy that Bill Morneau glossed over in his reaction.
- Carmichael also looks at the Bank of Canada’s decision to start treating climate change as an economic risk.
- Chantal Hébert isn’t seeing Maxime Bernier to be the threat to Andrew Scheer that some initially thought he might be.
- Chris Selley is sounding the alarm about the Liberals’ process for input on their media bailout package.
- My column looks at how the Liberals’ rush to pat themselves on the back for their changes to their appointments system may be premature.
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.
Terry Lake was far from being “retired” he was in fact a director for Hexo and I believe he is still. He by all accounts amassed a fortune in Hexo shares and I haven’t heard of his resignation. This is not a crime…he assisted the company through its growing years and was a leading advocate for legalization.