Roundup: The Conservatives’ anti-refugee inertia

Posted on by

With opinion galvanizing around the Syrian refugee crisis, there are calls for the government to do more – even if the opposition parties’ targets remain a little on the weak side in the overall picture. Cities and provinces – in particular Quebec – are pledging to do more, but they are bound by the pace that the federal government sets. And above all, that is the real problem with Canada’s response. Chris Alexander has been subtly blaming the UNHCR for their slow and onerous process while trying to cast his government in a positive light for trying to change that, except they’re the ones who’ve made the system far more onerous in the first place. I’ve covered the refugee file for a number of years, most especially when I was writing for Xtra, and a consistent theme emerged was that every time the Conservatives changed the rules, they were making it harder for refugees to make it into the country. In a particular bid to try to keep out refugee groups that they didn’t want to deal with – Mexicans and Roma are two that immediately come to mind – they continually tinkered with the rules, going so far as to create a “designated country of origin” list to make it easier to reject and deport those groups, no matter that a high volume of them had legitimate claims. They shortened processing times on arrival to prejudice the system against them, particularly when it’s difficult to get documentation, and denied them avenues of appeal. And overseas, they’ve understaffed embassies and missions in areas with high refugee populations and outsourced refugee determination to the UNHCR, which doesn’t have the resources and capacity to do that. Here in Canada, they’ve shifted their focus to private sponsorship away from government sponsorship, and even when they try to assist private groups, they don’t give them the assistance that they really required, such as capacity building. And then there was the whole issue of cutting off healthcare for refugee claimants, which was also used as a means of disincentivising people from coming over. Add to this a focus on risk assessment and then prioritizing minority populations in places like Syria and Iraq, and suddenly it’s no wonder that they’re moving at a glacial pace when it comes to getting more refugees resettled in Canada. The lack of political will to tackle this refugee crisis has been long-standing and a long time in the making. There are plenty of things that they could do, as Joe Clark explained, such as putting people on the ground in the region, doing security checks there, relieving the UNCHR of all of the work of refugee status determination, and arranging transportation rather than offering them loans for it (because if there’s one thing that refugees need it’s to be nickel-and-dimed by the Canadian government). They have the capacity, but they’ve spent so long trying to choke off the flow of refugees that the law of inertia has taken hold, and they can’t turn the ship around. I don’t think enough people are calling them out on this fact.

On the campaign:

  • Stephen Harper promised a reserve unit in the Yukon, as well as some northern tourist promotion.
  • Thomas Mulcair reiterated his public pensions pledge, and appealed to Quebec’s historical pacifism.
  • Justin Trudeau promised new investments in public transit, which a third of his infrastructure spending has been promised to go toward.
  • Here’s the leaders’ tours roundup for Friday.

Good reads:

  • Job numbers are up, but so is unemployment, because this is the wackiest recession ever. But Joe Oliver is all about pumping up the positives.
  • Here’s a look at our changing job market. While employment is increasing, job growth isn’t keeping pace with population growth.
  • Our frigates are getting new navigation radars, while our sole remaining destroyer suffered an engine room fire (but seems limited).
  • Scott Reid says that politics today turned Chris Alexander into a snarling partisan, but I don’t buy that. He has a choice in his behaviour.
  • Susan Delacourt writes about the refugee crisis and what it may do to the electorate.

Odds and ends:

More stock photo fun, as the Conservatives used an Oregon lake to advertise their conservation pledge.

The Conservatives also shot a “congratulatory” video about Halifax shipbuilding…in Ontario. So there’s that.