Roundup: Trying to politicize the GG

Posted on by

In a move so stunningly boneheaded that I can scarcely believe it, the NDP have gone to Rideau Hall to ask the Governor General to wade in on the Senate residency issue – because there’s nothing like trying to politicise the GG to show that you mean business about a petty issue. It’s like Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition doesn’t have a clue about what Responsible Government – the central organising principle of our democratic system – actually means. Here’s a refresher for their edification – the Governor General acts on the advice of the Prime Minister because the Prime Minister holds the confidence of the House of Commons, which is the chamber elected for the purpose of granting or withholding said confidence. The entire history of the struggle for Responsible Government in the colonies that became Canada, back in the 1830s, was because they wanted to control the appointments made by the Crown, rather than leave it up to the colonial masters in the UK. The entire history of Canadian democracy rests on the fact that it’s the elected government that advises the Crown on who to appoint, and not the other way around. And yet the NDP seem to suddenly think it’s cool to ask the GG to weigh in on which appointments he thinks are okay or not. Charlie Angus may tell you that he’s asking for an explanation and that he’s not trying to draw the GG into the “scandal,” but with all due respect, that’s a load of utter horseshit and he knows it. He’s trying to get the GG to tell him that the PM is wrong so that he has “non-partisan” authority to make the claim for him; that’s never going to happen. Ever. It is assumed that the advice the PM gives the GG is legitimate because the PM has the confidence of the Commons. That means that the quality of that advice is a ballot box issue – if we don’t like it, we get to hold that PM and that government to account by voting them out. It is not up to the GG to veto it unless it’s so egregious that it’s a blatant violation of the constitution, at which point he refuses the advice and the Prime Minister is forced to resign. But as much as Charlie Angus might like to think that Mike Duffy is some unprecedented scandal that rocks the very legitimacy of the Upper Chamber (which they don’t believe is legitimate anyway, so this is grade-A concern trolling on his part), it’s not a constitutional crisis. It’s just not. Even if Harper’s advice was dubious, it was up to Duffy to ensure that he lived up to the terms of that appointment, and ensuing he was a proper resident of PEI – which essentially would have meant a hasty house sale in Ottawa, buying a year-round residence on the Island (and not a summer cottage) tout suit, and then maybe renting an apartment or buying a small condo near Parliament Hill as his Ottawa pied à terre, being a legitimate secondary residence. Duffy did not do that. He instead got political opinions to ensure that he was okay with the summer cottage and a driver’s licence and that’s it, when clearly that was not enough. He bears as much culpability in this as the PM for making the appointment – not the GG. Charlie Angus should be utterly ashamed for this blatant attempt to politicise the GG, but I’m pretty sure he’s incapable of shame.

Good reads:

  • Thomas Mulcair decries that Stephen Harper’s absences are a “lack of respect” for Parliament or voters. Except that Mulcair himself is absent just about as often.
  • One of Jason Kenney’s staffers accepting gala tickets turned into a perfect excuse for the Ethics Commissioner to crack down (with what limited power she has).
  • Rising oil sands emissions means that we really aren’t likely to meet targets without buying offset credits, which this government used to denounce.
  • Princess Anne’s visit cost $128,000, which is cheap for a Royal, and pretty in keeping with her workhorse persona (and stop obsessing about how much royal tours cost already!)
  • I’m generally sceptical of crowdsourced reports, but the Privacy Commissioner thinks this one on privacy rights is pretty decent.
  • The new Chinook helicopter squadron should be fully operational at Petawawa by next summer.
  • Paul Wells notes the Conservatives’ habitual pre-election rattling starting up again.

Odds and ends:

NDP MP Matthew Dubé says that Jack Layton’s death made the party stronger…while they continue to use his ghost as a campaign prop.

Calgary businesswoman Lois Mitchell is Alberta’s new Lieutenant Governor.

The PMO acknowledged the French Monarchy as part of Canada’s history, possibly for the first time, on Victoria Day.